Skip to content
ERP Upgrade

The Hidden Costs of Custom Code Refactoring During ERP Upgrades

Discover the often-overlooked financial and operational risks of refactoring custom code during ERP upgrades. Learn how to assess dependencies, manage technical debt, and control costs to ensure a successful migration.

9 min readSysGenPro Editorial
The Hidden Costs of Custom Code Refactoring During ERP Upgrades

The Hidden Costs of Custom Code Refactoring During ERP Upgrades

The primary hidden cost of custom code refactoring during ERP upgrades is the significant underestimation of labor hours required to adapt, test, and validate legacy customizations against new system versions. This often leads to budget overruns and project delays. Custom code, including modules, workflows, and integrations, is rarely designed with future version compatibility in mind. When an ERP system is upgraded, underlying APIs, data models, and security frameworks often change. Refactoring this code is not a simple copy-paste operation; it requires a deep technical audit, strategic decision-making on what to keep, rewrite, or discard, and rigorous regression testing. The main risks to control include broken business processes, data integrity issues, and prolonged downtime. To mitigate these, organizations must treat custom code refactoring as a distinct workstream with its own budget, timeline, and quality gates, rather than an afterthought in the upgrade plan.

Understanding the Scope of Custom Code Technical Debt

Technical debt in an ERP environment accumulates over years of incremental changes. Custom code is often written to solve immediate business problems without considering long-term maintainability or alignment with vendor best practices. Before initiating an upgrade, it is critical to quantify this debt. This involves identifying all custom modules, stored procedures, API endpoints, and user interface modifications. Each component must be assessed for its dependency on specific ERP version features. For example, a custom report might rely on a database view that is deprecated in the target version. A workflow automation might use an API that has been replaced by a new service-oriented architecture. The cost of refactoring is directly proportional to the complexity and age of this code. Older code with poor documentation and high coupling to the core system will incur the highest refactoring costs. Organizations should conduct a code audit to categorize customizations into three buckets: those that can be migrated with minor tweaks, those requiring significant refactoring, and those that should be replaced by standard ERP features or third-party add-ons.

Categorizing Customizations for Cost Estimation

Accurate cost estimation requires a granular view of each custom component. A simple line-item count is insufficient. Instead, use a complexity matrix that scores each customization based on its size, coupling, and business criticality. High-criticality, high-complexity items should be prioritized for early refactoring and testing. Low-criticality items might be candidates for deferral or replacement. This categorization helps in allocating resources effectively. It also provides a basis for negotiating with system integrators or internal development teams. By understanding the scope, finance leaders can approve realistic budgets that account for the hidden labor costs of debugging and re-testing. This approach prevents the common scenario where the upgrade project runs out of funds before the custom code is fully validated.

The Impact of Deprecated APIs and Changed Data Models

One of the most significant drivers of refactoring costs is the deprecation of APIs and changes to data models. ERP vendors frequently update their core data structures to improve performance or add new features. These changes can break custom code that directly accesses database tables or uses legacy API endpoints. For instance, if a custom module inserts data into a specific table, and the vendor changes the table schema or moves the data to a new service, the module will fail. Refactoring requires rewriting the data access layer to use the new, supported interfaces. This is not just a technical task; it often requires a re-evaluation of the business logic. The new API might enforce different validation rules or require additional parameters. Developers must spend time understanding the new vendor documentation and adapting the code accordingly. This process is time-consuming and error-prone if not managed carefully. It is essential to verify compatibility against the vendor's official documentation for the exact source and target versions, as generic upgrade guides may not cover all edge cases.

Managing Third-Party Add-On Dependencies

Many ERP systems rely on third-party add-ons for specific functionalities, such as e-commerce integration, advanced analytics, or industry-specific modules. These add-ons are also subject to version compatibility issues. If a third-party add-on is not updated to support the new ERP version, it may need to be refactored or replaced. This adds another layer of complexity and cost. Organizations must coordinate with third-party vendors to ensure that their add-ons are compatible with the target ERP version. If the vendor does not provide an updated version, the organization may need to hire developers to patch the add-on or find an alternative solution. This can lead to delays and increased costs. It is crucial to include third-party add-on compatibility checks in the early stages of the upgrade planning. This allows for early identification of potential issues and provides time to seek alternative solutions if necessary.

Strategic Decisions: Refactor, Rewrite, or Replace

Not all custom code should be refactored. In some cases, it is more cost-effective to rewrite the module from scratch using modern development practices or to replace it with a standard ERP feature or a third-party add-on. The decision to refactor, rewrite, or replace should be based on a cost-benefit analysis. Refactoring is appropriate when the custom code provides unique business value that cannot be replicated by standard features. Rewriting is suitable when the existing code is too complex or poorly structured to be maintained. Replacing is the best option when the functionality is available in the standard ERP or through a reputable third-party add-on. This strategic decision-making process helps in reducing long-term maintenance costs and improving system stability. It also aligns the ERP system with best practices and vendor recommendations. By making these decisions early, organizations can avoid the trap of perpetuating technical debt and ensure a more sustainable ERP environment.

Decision OptionWhen to UseCost ImplicationRisk Level
RefactorUnique business logic, high value, moderate complexityMediumMedium
RewritePoor code quality, high complexity, high valueHighLow
ReplaceStandard feature available, low unique valueLowLow

The Role of Testing in Controlling Refactoring Costs

Testing is the most critical phase in controlling the hidden costs of custom code refactoring. Inadequate testing leads to defects that are discovered in production, resulting in emergency fixes, downtime, and reputational damage. A comprehensive testing strategy should include unit tests, integration tests, and end-to-end business process tests. Unit tests verify that individual components of the refactored code work as expected. Integration tests ensure that the custom code interacts correctly with the core ERP system and other modules. End-to-end tests simulate real-world business scenarios to validate that the entire process works seamlessly. User acceptance testing (UAT) is also essential to ensure that the refactored code meets business requirements. By investing in thorough testing, organizations can identify and fix defects early, reducing the cost of remediation. It also provides confidence that the upgraded system is stable and reliable.

Automating Regression Testing

Manual testing is time-consuming and prone to human error. Automating regression testing is a key strategy for controlling costs and improving efficiency. Automated tests can be run repeatedly and quickly, allowing developers to verify that their changes have not broken existing functionality. This is particularly important for custom code that is tightly coupled with the core ERP system. By automating regression tests, organizations can reduce the time spent on manual testing and free up resources for other critical tasks. It also ensures consistency and accuracy in testing results. However, automating tests requires an initial investment in time and resources. Therefore, it is important to prioritize the most critical business processes for automation. This approach provides a good balance between cost and benefit.

Planning for Downtime and Cutover

Custom code refactoring often requires downtime for deployment and validation. Planning for downtime is a critical aspect of the upgrade project. The cutover plan should include a detailed schedule for deploying the refactored code, running final tests, and switching to the new system. It should also include a rollback plan in case of critical issues. The rollback plan should specify the criteria for triggering a rollback and the steps to restore the system to its previous state. By having a well-defined cutover plan, organizations can minimize downtime and ensure a smooth transition to the new system. It also provides a safety net in case of unexpected issues. This is particularly important for businesses that rely on their ERP system for critical operations.

Post-Upgrade Stabilization and Monitoring

The upgrade project does not end with the cutover. Post-upgrade stabilization is a critical phase that ensures the system is stable and performing as expected. This involves monitoring the system for any issues, such as performance degradation, data inconsistencies, or user complaints. It also involves providing support to users and addressing any questions or concerns. By actively monitoring the system, organizations can identify and resolve issues quickly, minimizing their impact on business operations. It also provides valuable feedback for future upgrades. Post-upgrade stabilization is an ongoing process that requires dedicated resources and attention. By investing in this phase, organizations can ensure a successful and sustainable ERP upgrade.

Financial Implications and Budget Control

The hidden costs of custom code refactoring can have a significant impact on the overall budget of an ERP upgrade project. These costs include labor hours for developers, testers, and project managers, as well as the cost of tools and infrastructure. To control these costs, organizations should establish a clear budget for the refactoring workstream and track expenses regularly. They should also define clear acceptance criteria for each refactoring task to avoid scope creep. By maintaining strict budget control, organizations can ensure that the upgrade project stays within its financial constraints. This is essential for the long-term success of the project and the organization's financial health.

Cost CategoryDescriptionMitigation Strategy
Labor CostsDeveloper and tester hoursAccurate estimation, automation
Tooling CostsTesting and deployment toolsLeverage existing licenses
Downtime CostsLost productivity during cutoverMinimize downtime, plan carefully
Remediation CostsFixing defects in productionThorough testing, quality gates

Conclusion: Proactive Management of Custom Code

The hidden costs of custom code refactoring during ERP upgrades are a significant risk that can be mitigated through proactive management. By understanding the scope of technical debt, making strategic decisions on refactoring, rewriting, or replacing, and investing in thorough testing, organizations can control costs and ensure a successful upgrade. It is essential to treat custom code refactoring as a distinct workstream with its own budget, timeline, and quality gates. By doing so, organizations can protect their business data, maintain operational continuity, and improve long-term ERP maintainability. The key is to start early, plan carefully, and execute with precision. This approach will help organizations navigate the complexities of ERP upgrades and achieve their business goals.

Written by
SysGenPro Editorial

SysGenPro Editorial

Platform & solutions team

Practical guidance on ERP, AI automation, cloud deployment and enterprise transformation from the SysGenPro team.

Share this article

Frequently asked questions

Common questions on this topic. Talk to our team for anything specific to your business.

01How much does it cost to refactor custom ERP code?

The cost varies widely based on the complexity and size of the custom code. It can range from a few thousand dollars for minor tweaks to hundreds of thousands for major rewrites. Accurate estimation requires a detailed code audit.

02What is the biggest risk in ERP custom code upgrades?

The biggest risk is breaking critical business processes due to incompatibility with the new ERP version. This can lead to downtime, data loss, and financial losses.

03How do I identify deprecated APIs in my ERP system?

Review the vendor's official documentation for the target version. Use code analysis tools to scan for deprecated API calls. Consult with the vendor or a system integrator for specific guidance.

04Should I rewrite or refactor custom ERP modules?

Refactor if the code is well-structured and provides unique value. Rewrite if the code is poorly structured or too complex. Replace if standard features or third-party add-ons can meet the requirements.

05How long does custom code refactoring take during an upgrade?

The duration depends on the scope and complexity. It can take weeks or months. It is essential to include a buffer in the project timeline for unexpected issues.

06Can I avoid refactoring by using standard ERP features?

Yes, in many cases. Replacing custom code with standard features can reduce costs and improve maintainability. However, this requires a thorough analysis of business requirements.

Continue learning
View all articles
Explore the platform

Where to go next

Browse the knowledge hub

See how SysGenPro fits your business

Discuss your workflows, modules and deployment options with our team.

Back to resources